University dons have criticised the removal of fuel subsidy by President Bola Tinubu’s administration, describing the policy as poorly implemented, lacking accountability and transparency, and failing to deliver measurable benefits to Nigerians.
The academics, who spoke at the Founders’ Day edition of the Brown Bag Seminar organised by the School of Business and Entrepreneurship, American University of Nigeria (AUN), Yola, at the weekend, said they were not opposed to subsidy removal in principle but faulted the manner in which the policy was introduced without adequate consultation, public communication and a clear framework to cushion its impact on citizens.
The seminar, themed “Nigeria PMS (Fuel) Subsidy Reform: Strategy, Accountability,or Survival? brought together university scholars to examine the economic and social consequences of the policy, particularly its implications for household welfare, businesses and the wider Nigerian economy.
The dons argued that while the government had justified the removal on the grounds of reducing public expenditure and redirecting savings to development, they said there was no evidence of transparent accounting of the funds saved or tangible improvements in the living conditions of ordinary Nigerians.
Speaking at the event, Professor Haruna Isa Mohammed, described subsidy removal strategy as government declaring war on its citizens, arguing that the government had withdrawn a benefit enjoyed by citizens without putting adequate measures in place to protect them from the resulting economic shocks.
Haruna, a professor of Strategic Management, likened the policy’s implementation to a situation in which the government had turned against the very citizens it was expected to protect.
“The strategy used in removing it is wrong. The linkages we have are 10 times worse than what we lost on subsidy,” he said.
“You cannot remove subsidy and, at the same time, devalue the naira,” he said, cautioning that continued economic pressure, coupled with the government’s growing dependence on borrowing, could push the country towards deeper economic instability.
The professor further questioned the government’s approach to managing public resources, insisting that subsidy removal should not be treated as the only viable means of generating revenue or reducing expenditure.
In his contribution, Professor Sakah Mahmud questioned the government’s ability to rebuild public trust and sustain the legitimacy of the reform, arguing that citizens had been made to bear the heaviest cost of a policy they were neither adequately consulted on nor properly prepared for.
Mahmud, a Professor of Political Science and International Studies, said the absence of a national debate, effective communication and transparent implementation process had undermined public confidence in the policy
“There was no national debate on it, there was no communication. There was nothing reasonable about this policy,”he said.
He maintained that the government had failed to establish the necessary social contract with Nigerians before introducing a reform with such far-reaching consequences.
Mahmud also challenged the argument that fuel subsidy was an unsustainable economic practice, pointing out that several countries, including Egypt, Mozambique, Malaysia, Indonesia, India and Thailand, operate different forms of fuel subsidy or energy support programmes.
He further cited countries in Europe and other developed economies, including the United Kingdom, France, Germany and the United States, as examples of countries that maintain various forms of support for their energy sectors.
According to him, the existence of such policies elsewhere demonstrates that there is no single approach to subsidy reform and that Nigeria must adopt policies that reflect its peculiar economic realities and the welfare of its citizens.
For Dr. Ibrahim Hamid, the absence of verifiable figures on subsidy savings and their utilisation had made it difficult for Nigerians to assess the actual benefits of the policy.
“ No one can tell the specific amount that has been saved from subsidy or how much has been spent. What we have are only estimated figures,” Hamid said.
He added that the absence of measurable impacts from the purported savings had raised serious questions about accountability and transparency, making it increasingly difficult for the government to convince Nigerians that the policy was necessary and beneficial.
According to him, the government must demonstrate clearly how the resources saved from subsidy removal have been deployed and the extent to which they have improved citizens’ welfare.
The academics consequently called for greater transparency in the management of subsidy savings.
UPDATE NEWS:
Nigerians can now invest ₦2.5 million on premium domains and profit about ₦17-₦25 million. All earnings paid in US Dollars. Rather than wonder,
click here to find out how it works.
No Comment! Be the first one.